Hyperhidrosis Treatments: A Comparison of Botox, Perspirex, and Pro-Banthine - Mona Clinic
目次
Are you unable to wear light-colored clothes due to sweat stains, or do documents get damp from sweaty hands? Does sweating worsen when you're nervous in front of people? Hyperhidrosis is a condition that impacts daily life more than it appears. Many people give up, thinking it's "just how my body is," but there are several effective treatments available at medical institutions.
In this article, a Mona Clinic doctor explains two treatment methods in detail, including their mechanisms and comparisons: Perspirex (topical), which can be prescribed through online consultation, and Botox injections, which are administered in person.
What is Hyperhidrosis?
Hyperhidrosis is a condition characterized by excessive sweating beyond the amount needed for body temperature regulation. It is categorized into "primary hyperhidrosis," which occurs in specific areas (such as armpits, palms, soles of feet, or face), and "secondary hyperhidrosis," which occurs as a side effect of other diseases or medications. Primary hyperhidrosis, often with an unknown cause, is believed to be related to overactivity of the sympathetic nervous system.
Do any of these symptoms sound familiar?
- Sweating concentrated in specific areas (armpits, palms, soles of feet, etc.)
- Little sweating during sleep (a characteristic of primary hyperhidrosis)
- Sudden increase in sweating when feeling tense or anxious
- Excessive sweating that interferes with daily life at least once a week
- Having to choose clothes based on color or material due to sweat stains
- Difficulty in situations such as holding hands or signing documents
Hyperhidrosis Treatment: Two Options
There are several approaches to treating hyperhidrosis, each with different mechanisms and durations of effect. It is important to choose based on the severity, location of your symptoms, and lifestyle.
| Treatment Method | Availability | Mechanism | Duration of Effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Perspirex | Online (topical) | Forms a keratin plug "lid" at the opening of sweat glands, physically suppressing sweat. | 3-5 days (requires continuous use) |
| Botox Injection | In-person | Blocks the action of neurotransmitters that stimulate sweat glands. | Around 3 months |
For those who want to start easily at home, Perspirex is recommended. For those who seek significant results, even if it means clinic visits, Botox injections are more suitable.
① Botox Injection (In-person)
Botox injection is a treatment method that temporarily stops the function of sweat glands themselves by suppressing the release of acetylcholine, a neurotransmitter that promotes sweating. It is mainly used for armpit hyperhidrosis and is chosen by those who seek strong, localized effects. If diagnosed with severe primary axillary hyperhidrosis, it may be covered by insurance.
Procedure Flow
- ① Visit & Counseling: Confirm the severity of symptoms and areas of concern.
- ② Treatment: Injections at multiple points according to sweat gland distribution (estimated time: 15-30 minutes).
- ③ Feeling the Effect: Reduction in sweating is usually noticeable a few days to a week after the procedure.
- ④ Duration of Effect: Lasts approximately 3 months, then gradually returns to normal, requiring regular procedures.
Features
- Quick onset of effect and strong results can be achieved.
- Clinic visits (in-person consultation) are essential due to injections.
- Can be applied to areas other than armpits (palms, soles), but these areas can be painful, so please consult in advance.
- Rarely, bruising at the injection site or temporary muscle weakness may occur.
Recommended for:
- Those seeking strong results for armpit hyperhidrosis.
- Those who prefer to visit the clinic once every few months.
- Those who found Perspirex's effects insufficient.
Book Botox Injection in-person
② Perspirex (Online Prescription・Topical)
Perspirex is a medical antiperspirant containing a high concentration of aluminum chloride. It works by creating a "keratin plug" that reacts with sweat at the opening of the sweat glands, physically suppressing sweat secretion. Unlike over-the-counter antiperspirants, it doesn't just temporarily reduce sweat; it weakens the function of the sweat glands themselves. Originally developed in Denmark, it has a long track record of use in medical settings, primarily in Europe.
Choosing the Right Type
| Type | Features | Recommended for |
|---|---|---|
| Original | Standard strength | First-time users, those concerned about sweat and odor |
| Strong | More powerful antiperspirant effect | Those for whom the Original was not sufficiently effective |
| Comfort | Low-irritation formula for sensitive skin | Those with sensitive skin who found the Original irritating |
Features
- Apply before bed; no need to reapply during the day.
- Effects last about 3-5 days; typically used 2-3 times a week.
- Can be used on armpits, palms, and soles of feet.
- May cause tingling or itching when first used.
- Available for prescription via online consultation and mailed directly, with same-day shipping possible.
Recommended for:
- Those who want to manage symptoms at home without clinic visits.
- Those who want to treat hyperhidrosis in areas other than armpits (hands, feet).
- Those who want to try a less invasive method first.
For detailed instructions on how to use Perspirex and common mistakes, please refer to this separate article.
About Propantheline Bromide (Oral Medication)
Propantheline bromide, an oral medication for generalized sweating, is also available, but its prescription is temporarily suspended due to inventory issues. If you are concerned about generalized sweating, please consult with us during your examination about using Perspirex on multiple areas or a combination with Botox injections.
Choosing a Treatment Method
| Concern/Preference | Suitable Treatment Method |
|---|---|
| Want to manage at home, use on hands/feet, try an easy method first | Perspirex |
| Want to strongly suppress armpit sweat, seek high efficacy even with clinic visits | Botox Injection |
| Want to treat multiple areas | Consider using Perspirex and Botox for different areas |
For example, you can discuss using Botox for armpits and Perspirex for palms during your consultation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Since they target different areas and purposes, they can often be used together. We will suggest based on your symptoms during consultation.
While individual results vary, effects often diminish after about 3 months. We recommend regular treatments if you wish to maintain the effect.
Hyperhidrosis treatments aim to reduce the amount of sweat itself, which can consequently lead to a reduction in odor. If odor is your primary concern, please discuss it in detail during your consultation.
Perspirex can be used on the palms. For severe cases, a combination with Botox injections or Propantheline Bromide might be considered, so please consult us during your examination.
It is currently temporarily unavailable due to a nationwide shipping suspension. If you are concerned about generalized sweating, please consult us about treatment options with Perspirex or Botox.
